Thursday, December 29, 2011

►Deconstruction and the Visual Arts: Art, Media, Architecture

Peter Brunette and David Wills: Deconstruction and the Visual Arts: Art, Media, Architecture 


This collection of essays provides a forum that represents new approaches to the study of the visual arts. The authors in this anthology deal with the applicability of the ideas of the French philosopher Jacques Derrida to the visual and media arts and to architecture. Although a number of works clearly influenced by deconstruction have began to appear in these fields, this edition brings together for the first time a group of previously unpublished essays that will be of interest to scholars of visual theory and spatial arts in general.
In the case of the visual arts, the work, as Derrida reminds us, is conceived of as a receptacle or dwelling place for meaning, one whose borders are both clearly defined and consistently repressed to provide the spectator with easy access to its centre and seat. In this respect Derrida's philosophical inquiry is exemplary, and the structural resemblance between linguistic and visual or architectural models is reinforced, for the hierarchical relation between speech and writing that deconstruction analyses and seeks to displace is traditionally described in terms of that between an inside and an outside. Speech is held to remain within the closed circuit defined by the speaker and listener, disappearing into the fold of immediate comprehension, forgetting the spacing that constitutes it. Writing, on the other hand, cannot but fall outside, into an unavoidable materiality, and its materiality ensures that it will function outside of the control of its producer, from where it will always threaten the integrity of the supposed intact system of speech. The means by which speech then both rejects and co-opts writing in order to perpetuate its position of priority - indeed, the means by which this operation repeats itself throughout any areas of Westem thinking - has been refered to by Derrida as an `economy', from the Hellenic (oikos) for `house'. Derrida's work aims to break down or re-arrange the walls of that house, exposing its inside to previously unseen aspects of its outside, reconstructing different accomodations of space, forcing different means of access, reworking its principles of what it contains.
In the first chapter of this book, the idea of deconstruction whose limits are constantly being worked at and expanded, is discussed at some length by Derrida in an interview by the editors, and so the collection 'opens'. Derrida's comments on deconstruction's relation to high technology are of particular interest here. Although the question concerning high technology remains for the most part of the book, it is clear that it is beginning, through various techniques such as the computer generated image, to impose its relevance on the media arts (film, television and video), as well as on `art' traditionally conceived, and indeed on architectural design.
The introductory chapter and the essays that follow are roughly divided by the editors into five groups. The first group outlines the theoretical implications of an "importation" of deconstruction into the visual arts. The first chapter provides the problematics that are the focus of the later essays: the question of Derrida's competence in fields other than philosophy. Throughout the interview, Derrida reformulates the visual in terms of the spatial.
The author of the second essay, Stephen Melville, specifically considers the fact of colour and outlines ways in which deconstruction may alter one's approach to the art object and itself be altered by the encounter. In the third essay Mieke Bal considers the light in Vermeer's Woman Holding a Balance and questions art history's search for original intentions and interpretations. She does indeed explore deconstructive notions of intertextuality, polysemy, and in particular dissemination and hymen. The third essay, written by Marie-Clair Ropars - Wuilleunmier, looks at Derrida's reading of Kant and the aesthetic, and uses as resource the cinematic example of Godard's Passion (1983). This first section ends with Gregory Ulmer's contribution, which is a continuation of his "grammatological" project to translate deconstruction onto the pedagogical level as discovery or invention.
The second set of contributions address variations on the theme of "parergon" (the frame), and the question here is the boundaries between inside and out. Rodowick opens this section, arguing Derrida's deconstruction of Kant's Critique of Judegment, and, in fact, deconstructs the notion of the aesthetic itself which is very often considered in discussions about art. In the essay that follows, Lebensztein offers an exploration of multiple meanings and figurations of the physical frame as it has manifested itself through the history of art. In the final essay of this section, Donald Preziosi shows the importance of the museum itself as a powerful framing device with widespread political and theoretical consequences.
The inputs in the third section offer explicit applications of Derrida's deconstructive theory to painting and sculpture. Herman Rapaport, contradicts Rodowick's discussion by juxtaposing Heidegger and Derrida in a critique that is applied on the work of the sculptor Richard Long as a "restitution" of aesthetics. This idea of beauty after the dismantling of Kantian metaphysics is followed by Charles Altiery who similarly puts together Frank Stella and Derrida in his attempt to illuminate the work of each through a discussion of a very important new foundation of ethics on the ruins of deconstructed subject, and a challenging of the notion of human agency. The last contributor of this third group (John Leavey) meditates, inspired by the writings of Derrida, on the visual arts, more with than against Valerio Adami's painting Concerto a Quattro Mani.
The fourth group's opening contribution is written by Jennifer Bloomer who, in this inspired essay, blends autobiography, feminist theory and architectural project to give birth to a piece of writing that is as heterogeneous as the structures she has designed for Chicago street corners. Another substantial essay follows Bloomer's: that of Mark Wigley, who discusses ways in which the architecture of `the house' function in Derrida's work, following on from Heidegger's philosophical tradition before it became 'fashionable'.
The essays of the last group are perhaps the most interesting of all. These manifest possible applications of deconstruction to film and television. Laura Oswald, in 'Cinema-Graphia: Eisenstein, Derrida, and the Sign of Cinema', compares Derrida's and Eisenstein's notions of the ideogram. In an intriguing debate, she finds that Eisenstein's cinematic practice is more radical than his writings. She then elaborates on her concept of 'cinema-graphia'. This is followed by Ingham's deconstuctive and anthropological approach to film. He politicises, together with Tom Conley, a quintessential manifestation of popular culture, Beverley Hills Cop. A trip into 1930s and 1940s popular culture follows, where Robert Ray offers an example of an 'alternative' deconstructive practice in the form of an application of the signature effect to Hollywood Andy Hardy movies. This last section closes with R. Dienst's rethinking of discourses of television studies by using Derrida's idea of the Postal (The Post Card) and is developed in Sending Postcards in TV Land. Dienst concludes this group with A Postal Axiom: "And the television has been on all this time - we know that much".
As the reader realises by now, this anthology cannot serve adequately, on its own, as an introduction to such a complex field as deconstruction for those with no previous knowledge of it. It is, however, an ideal collection of contributions for Derrida's readers and for cultural studies readers, for it offers a unique insight of his accounts being applied from aesthetics and art history to film, television, and architecture.

►Deconstruction: Architecture and Design

The term “Deconstruction” which rose to prominence in the mid-1980s, has become a convenient label to pin on unorthodox design approaches within a seemingly diverse range of creative disciplines. From architecture to fashion and graphic design, asymmetric, chopped-up and fragmented forms are often the hallmarks of designs which are categorized by the term. Yet the concept of  ‘deconstruction’ is notoriously difficult to pin down and arose from the often difficult and at times, seemingly impenetrable work of a French philosopher and theorist, Jacques Derrida. How did deconstruction, with its origins in philosophy and literary academia, come to have such a profound effect on the wider spheres of art and science? And does deconstruction still have anything to offer the web designer looking for critical approaches to well established standardised industry practices? In attempting to answer these questions, I will show that deconstruction, if not in practise, then at least in spirit, still lives in some of the more exotic corners of the Web.

Jaques Derrida (1930 – 2004)

In many ways, Derrida, who experienced the institutionalized anti-Semitism endemic in French colonial Algeria as a young man 1, had a special sensitivity to the themes of identification and the marginal which are at the core of his philosophical arguments 2.  For him, most of Western philosophical thinking was founded on a series of generalized assumptions, which accorded a bogus privileged status to particular modes of thought and lines of enquiry. Deconstruction subjects to scrutiny many of these foundational concepts of Western “metaphysical” thinking. Derrida defines metaphysics thus:
“The enterprise of returning “strategically”, ideally, to an origin, or to a “priority” held to be simple, intact, normal, pure, standard, self-identical, in order, then to think in terms of derivation, complication, deterioration, accident, etc. All metaphysicians, from Plato to Rousseau, Descartes to Husserl, have proceeded in this way, conceiving good before evil, the positive before the negative, the pure before the impure, the simple before the complex, the essential before the accidental, the imitated before the imitation, etc. And this is not just one metaphysical gesture among others: It is the metaphysical exigency, that which has been the most constant, most profound, and most potent.” 3
Such enquiries into abstract notions of essential being and truth are centred on a fundamental grounding principle, a fixed origin, or logos, hence logocentrism: a “system of speech, consciousness, meaning, presence, truth etc, which is itself an effect – an effect to be analysed – of a more and more powerful historical unfolding of general writing.” 4  5
Derrida built on the work of Structuralists such as Swiss linguist, Ferdinand de Saussaure, who identified the tendency for humans to establish meaning by thinking in terms of hierarchical opposites in his work on semiotics. These binary oppositions are key relationships in Structuralist analysis but Derrida takes them further: it is in the nature of metaphysical thinking, having established an opposing hierarchy, to favour one over the other and to accord it a positive, privileged status. Such binary opposites include:
  • Life/Death
  • True/False
  • Being/Non-being
  • Inside/Outside
  • Original/Copy
  • Presence/Absence
  • Male/Female
  • Real/Imaginary
  • Speech/Writing
It is the speech/writing axis that Derrida confronts in Of Grammatology 6. Derrida argues that since Plato, philosophers have favoured speech as a purer, more authentic, representative expression of thought than writing: writing is derivative and inferior, a mere writing down of something that is already there. Thus speech is fully present to thought and to the self whereas writing is absent. However, for Derrida, writing is to be considered as more than the merely graphic or inscriptional, and is in fact the precondition of language 7. Derrida inverts the opposition: writing is itself a memory system, a type of speech that is capable of storing thought for future transmission. So Derrida disrupts the binary opposition: speech / writing is no longer an either/or structure but rather an “undecidable”.8
This appears to chime with Saussaure’s structuralist reading of linguistic meaning and signs. Here, the binary opposition is signifier vs. signified but for a sign to function, it needs the presence of both signifier andall meaning, is derived wholly from its difference to other sounds or letters. For Derrida, this difference is the ‘undecidabilty’ that destabilizes any notion of pure meaning, that is, it is at once, both within and absent from the signifier.9 signified. So one cannot be favoured, even if metaphysical interpretations would favour the signifier as ‘closer’ to pure thought. The signifer is the sonic sound of the spoken word or written letter, and is purely arbitrary: its meaning, hence
Deconstruction then, can be thought of as method of analytical enquiry, a procedure that seeks to uncover and decouple established hierarchical opposites through their inversion and subsequent destabilisation. The task is not yet complete however: the entire metaphysical edifice must be exposed and dismantled such that it may be in some way re-inscribed.
Deconstruction cannot limit itself or proceed immediately to a neutralization: it must, by means of a double gesture, a double science, a double writing, practice an overturning of the classical opposition and a general displacement of the system. It is only on this condition that Deconstruction will provide itself a means with which to intervene in the field of oppositions that it criticizes… 10
Deconstruction seeks to derail the system of established order from within, for example, by inhabiting a text in order to subvert it. Not in order to provide definitive new interpretations, but to reveal layers of meaning whilst at the same time leaving space for ambiguity.

Deconstruction in Architecture

Deconstruction as a critical approach rapidly spread far beyond the rarefied spheres of cultural studies  and academic philosophy, where many of his ideas were met with fierce resistance. The politically charged university campuses of the late 1970s and early 1980s proved highly receptive to radical new theories that sought to overturn the established order 11. Deconstruction was among the broader ‘post-structuralist’ field of critical studies that swept through academia, but its ambiguity and its preoccupations with language, knowledge, power, technology, media and institutions made its procedures widely applicable 12. In any field, Derridian methods might be applied to unpack specific dominant themes: male/female and father/mother in feminist and gender studies and so on.
In architecture, such pairings might include:
  • order/disorder
  • structure/chaos
  • ornament/purity
  • rationality/sensuality
  • form/function
These were identified in an article by Swiss architect, Bernard Tschumi 13, one of the seven architects who were featured in the 1988 landmark exhibition, “Deconstructivist Architecture” at the Museum of Modern Art in New York (MoMA). Curator Mark Wigley wrote the following in the programme notes:
“A deconstruction architect is not one who dismantles building but who locates the inherent dilemmas within the building. The deconstructive architect puts the pure forms of architectural tradition on the couch and identifies the symptoms of a repressed impurity. The impurity is drawn to the surface by a combination of gentle coaxing and violent torture. The form is interrogated”. 14
But how does Derrida’s inversions of textural structure lend itself to the construction of buildings? After all, a building must function first and foremost as a structure: it must have integrity. The answer lies in what another of the MoMA seven, Peter Eisenman terms, “the metaphysics of architecture” 15. By this he means breaking the rules of the established order. The use of Derridean terminology is explicit as he states:
“The need to overcome presence, the need to supplement an architecture that will always be and look like architecture, the need to break apart the strong bond between form and function, is what my architecture addresses. In its displacement of the traditional role of function it does not deny that architecture must function, but rather suggests that architecture may also function without necessarily symbolising that function, that the presentness of architecture is irreducible to the presence of its functions or its signs.” 16

Le Parc de la Vilette

Bernard Tschumi’s 1982 design for the regeneration of a run-down corner of suburban Paris was one of the first attempts at putting the concepts of Derridian theory into architectural practise. Tschumi labelled his scheme, “an architecture of disjunction” 17. It supports deconstructive concepts in that it inverts architectural assumptions about systems: points, surfaces and lines overlap and clash; the layout is ambiguous. In part, it deconstructs the Vitruvian values of commodity, firmness and delight 18. Derrida collaborated with Tschumi in the project and perhaps the clearest manifestation of deconstruction concepts is in the 41 pavilions or ‘folies’ (although only 35 were eventually built). These abstract, red steel structures were assigned a form before any function had been devised, thus applying an inversion to one of the tenets of modernist architecture.

Parc de la Villette, pavillion
As Tschumi writes:
“Theoretical architects – as they were called – wanted to confront the binary oppositions of traditional architecture: namely form versus function, or abstraction versus figuration. However, they also wanted to challenge the implied hierarchies hidden in these dualities, such as, “form follows function,” and “ornament is subservient to structure.” This repudiation of hierarchy led to a fascination with complex images that were simultaneously “both” and “neither/nor” – images that were the overlap or the superimposition of many other images. Superimposition became a key device.” 19
The collision of systems of lines, points and surfaces at Parc de la Villette is a means of avoiding any formal concept of compositions, such that any expression of hierarchy is avoided. The folies form an organising grid, an orienting device with no other meaning or purpose. Tschumi is setting in play spatial oppositions: presence/absence, inside/outside, norm/deviation.

Like Derrida, Tschumi and his contemporaries wanted to shake up the established order of things, to break the rules, not in a nihilistic way, but in a transformative engagement with the process: a way of reinterpreting the use of space, of “practising space” where:
“… concept and experience of space abruptly coincide, where architectural fragments collide and merge in delight, where the culture of architecture is endlessly deconstructed  and its rules transgressed. No metaphorical paradise here, but discomfort and unbalancing of expectations. Such architecture questions academic (and popular) assumptions, disturbs acquired taste and fond architectural memories. Typologies, morphologies, spatial compressions, logical constructions – all dissolve. Inarticulated forms collide in a staged and necessary conflict: repetition, discontinuity, quotes, clichés and neologism. Such architecture is perverse because its real significance lies outside any utility or purpose and ultimately is not even aimed at giving pleasure.”20
With Parc de La Villete, Tschumi rejects the notion of park as landscape or as an image of nature. His space is more that of an urban grid, albeit one that occurs in green space farther than on a street map. His superimposition of grids looks more like an exploded plan of an airport terminal. That is its aim: the park as building – “one of the largest buildings ever constructed.”

Deconstruction in Graphic Design

As we have seen, deconstruction’s analytical framework has provided a guiding methodology for certain practitioners within architecture. Has the same been true for graphic design? Designer Ellen Lupton’s excellent article on deconstruction in graphic design describes how the Deconstructivist architectural design style, showcased at the MoMA show of that title, provided a ready-made visual vocabulary for graphic designers looking to capture the Zeitgeist.14
“By framing their exhibition around a new “ism,” Wigley and Johnson helped to canonize the elements of a period style, marked by twisted geometries, centerless plans, and shards of glass and metal. This cluster of stylistic features quickly emigrated from architecture to graphic design, just as the icons and colors of neo-classical post-modernism had travelled there shortly before. 14
Subsequently, much of what became labelled as ‘deconstruction’ or ‘deconstructivist’ in graphic design was purely stylistic in content, lacking the theoretical framework to underpin the label whose title it had appropriated.21
Yet Derrida had already provided a blueprint for graphic designers in his radical approach to layout and typographic communication with his 1974 book, Glas 22. In Glas, Derrida juxtaposed two texts, by philosopher Georg Hegel and writer Jean Genet, in facing parallel columns with free-floating ‘footnotes’, discordant typography, inconsistent layout, collapsing margins and so on. By forcing the two texts together in this way: the bawdy prose of Genet with the ‘scientific’, emotionally detached logical reasoning of Hegel, Derrida is asking us to look for the in-between, the uncertain, that which is neither literature or philosophy. Derrida has “juxtaposed a coherent, seemingly self-complete literary artefact with a situation where external forces aggressively interfere with the sacred interior of content.” 14

Jacques Derrida, Glas. 1974

He is again, calling into question a set of formal structures: “indexes and title pages, captions and colophons, folios and footnotes, leading and line lengths, margins and marginalia, spacing and punctuation” 14 that constitute a mode of representation, destabilizing the hierarchies: inside/outside, left/right, ordered/disordered and so on.
The pinoneering work of designers Katherine and Michael McCoy at the design department of Cranbrook Acadamy of Art has been well documented. There, deconstruction as a theoretical approach was put into action in order to decode the elements of design: typography, language, ideas, mage, words, values. By setting these in play, the desired effect was to unbalance expectations with a Utopian desire to liberate the modes of communication from purely functional or commercial imperatives. To
“…challenge the sterility of ‘Universal Design’… consciously breaking virtually all the rules of the deadly seriousness and antiseptic discipline of objective Swiss rationalism. The emerging ideas emphasized the construction of meaning between the audience and the graphic design piece, a visual transaction that parallels verbal communication… New experiments explored the relationships of text and image and the processes of reading and seeing, with texts and images meant to be read in detail, their meanings decoded. Students began to deconstruct the dynamics of visual language and understand it as a filter that inescapably manipulates the audience’s response. 23
These approaches intended to destabilize concepts of authorship and meaning, placing the onus on the audience to construct its own, challenging them to “reconsider perceptions”.

Cranbrook graduate poster, 1989. Katherine McCoy: The use of binary oppositions in the text is explicit.
Allen Hori. Typography as Discourse. 1989
By the mid 1990s, the influence of the initial design pioneers had spread far beyond the design hothouses of the design departments like the one at Cranbrook, and the deconstruction or desconstructivist label began to be applied to a certain design aesthetic, devoid of its theoretical context. Often aided by newly available digital font authoring software such as Fontographer and desk-top publishing software based on the Macintosh platform, designers were free to create new bitmap type styles and a slew of ‘home-made’, ‘grunge’ fonts and experimental layouts became the basis for a new style anti-convention and the topic of heated debate within the wider design community and fought out in the pages of magazines such as Emigre. Criticized as the ‘cult of the ugly’ 24 this new-wave look opened a schism later dubbed the ‘Legibility Wars’ in the design press. However, as the look began to be co-opted by the more commercial mainstream print media, the ideological loading of the deconstruction label lightened and the meaning became diluted, ultimately becoming a fashionable shorthand for any kind of ‘analysis’ or ‘breaking apart’ 25.

Jeffery Keedy. Emigre Magazine. 1992.

Conclusion
As we have seen, the influence of deconstruction as a critical approach within the design fields has faded since its heyday in the 1990s: certainly the use of the term has declined since that era. However, the issues Derrida was concerned with still raise profound implications for today’s designer. Although web design is a relatively youthful design practice, it can draw lessons from both architecture and graphic design where deconstruction has had such an impact, even though the arguments it generated remain largely unresolved. Theoretical approaches are less commonly found in web design with its multi-disciplinary make-up, its reliance on industry standards and focus on clear communication and the user. Nevertheless, I have identified some areas where such an approach can lead to rich user experiences while allowing space to acknowledge the ambiguity inherent in interpreting visual communication.

References

1. Kirby, D., Kofman, A.Z. & Derrida, J., 2005. Derrida: screenplay and essays on the film, Volume 2005, Part 2, Manchester: Manchester University Press.

2. Attridge, D., 2004. Obituary: Jacques Derrida | World news | The Guardian. Available at:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/news/2004/oct/11/guardianobituaries.france
[Accessed January 10, 2011].

3. Derrida, J., 1988. Limited Inc, Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press.  p.93.

4. Esch, D., 1999. In the Event: Reading Journalism, Reading Theory (Meridian: Crossing Aesthetics), Stanford, California: Stanford University Press.  p.12

5. Reynolds, J., 2010. Derrida, Jacques. Available at: http://www.iep.utm.edu/derrida/ [Accessed January 25, 2011].

6. Derrida, J., 1998. Of Grammatology Corrected., Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press.

7. Norris, C., 2002. Deconstruction: Theory & Practise, London: Routledge.

8. Grenz, S.J., 1996. A Primer On Postmodernism, Grand Rapids, MI: William B Eerdmans Publishing.  p.149

9. Cusset, F., 2008. French Theory: how Foucault, Derrida, Deleuze, & Co. Transformed the Intellectual Life of the United States, Minnesota, MI: University of Minnesota Press.

10. Grenz, S.J., 1996. A Primer On Postmodernism, Grand Rapids, MI: William B Eerdmans Publishing.  p.149

11. Easthope, A., 2004. Difference. In K. McGowan, ed. A Critical and Cultural Theory Reader. Maidenhead: Open University Press.  

12. Seaver, G., 2007. The Ideological Basis to Affirmative Action and Diversity. American Civil Rights Institute.
Available at: http://www.acri.org/seaver_article.html [Accessed January 18, 2011].

13. Tshumi, B., 2001. The Pleasure of Architecture. In A. Ballantyne, ed. What is Architecture? London: Routledge.

14. Lupton, E., 2004. Typotheque: Deconstruction and Graphic Design: History Meets Theory by Ellen Lupton.
Available at: http://www.typotheque.com/articles/deconstruction_and_graphic_design_history_meets_theory [Accessed January 17, 2011].

15. Eisenman, P., 1996. Architecture and the Problem of the Rhetorical Figure. In K. Nesbitt, ed. Theorizing a New Agenda for Architecture: Anthology of Architectural Theory, 1965-95.
New York: Princeton Architectural Pres, pp. 176-181.

16. Eisenman, P., 1990. Post/El Cards: A Reply to Jacques Derrida. Assemblage, (12), pp.14-17.

17. Collins, J. & Mayblin, B., 2005. Introducing Derrida, Cambridge: Icon.

18. Turner, T., 1994. A review of Parc de la Villette, Paris. GardenVisit.com. Available at: http://www.gardenvisit.com/history_theory/library_online_ebooks/architecture_city_as_landscape/review_parc_de_la_villette_tom_turner [Accessed January 19, 2011].

19. Tschumi, B., 1996. Architecture and Disjunction, Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press.  p.251.

20. Tschumi, B., 1996. Architecture and Disjunction, Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press.  p.180.

21. Poynor, R., 2003. No More Rules : Graphic Design and Postmodernism, London: Laurence King. p.64

22. Derrida, J., 1990. Glas, University of Nebraska Press.

23. McCoy, K. & McCoy, M., 1990. High Ground Design : Essay-The New Discourse. High Ground Design.
Available at: http://www.highgrounddesign.com/mccoy/cran3.htm [Accessed January 21, 2011].

24. Heller, S., 1993. Cult of the Ugly. Eye, 3(9), pp.52-59.

25.  Poynor, R., 2003. No more rules : graphic design and postmodernism, London: Laurence King. p.65


►Graphic Design and Deconstruction

A brief critical analysis of one deconstructionist work of Graphic Design focusing on the aims of Deconstruction in Graphic Design.

A summary of Thinking with Type - Text
The definition of ‘text’ in typography is an ‘on-going sequence of words, distinct from headlines or captions.’ Text can be as flowing as a liquid or as solid as an object.  By breaking text up, offering shortcuts and alternate routes, design and typography provide readers ways of navigating the text. Ironically although typography is often defined as improving readability, design actually provides the reader with devices to avoid reading.
The literary notion of ‘the text’ being a complete, original work was facilitated by Typography.  Handwritten documents were laboriously crafted but subject to human error.  The invention of print allowed handwritten manuscripts to be corrected before they were printed.  The proof reader’s role was to ensure the printed text represented the original author’s work; however with each edition, translation, revision, and teaching the author’s original meaning changed.  
The continuous flow of spoken language does not need to offer breaks between words.  Written alphabetic writing needs spaces to make the words distinct, understandable units.  Typography made text an object with a fixed position.   
French philosopher Jacques Derrida wrote ‘that although the alphabet represents sounds it cannot function without silent marks and spaces’.     
Typography can be analyzed using the two opposing models of writing which the French critic, Roland Barthes used to describe literature.  The first a closed, fixed ‘work and the second an open, unstable ‘text’.  A metaphor for ‘text’ is that of network.  A typographic book has a fixed sequence of numbered pages which lends itself to provide the reader routes through the text with for example an index, appendix, table of contents.  These typographic mechanisms provide both entrance and escape from the linearity of text and also the author's original meaning.
The digital era appears to provide even more potential for nonlinear communication.  Ironically examples of linearity abounds from ‘crawling’ text on news screens to LED ticker style signs; electronic books are highly sequential and can be cumbersome in their linearity.
The database has non-linear form with information space which is accessed through menus and searches and then organised in countless sequences.
Typography has become more liquid, flexible and the use of space has become more refined.   
Lupton states:‘Reading is a performance of the written word’   By considering Barthe’s model of text as an open web of references we can understand the significance of the reader creating meaning rather than the writer. ‘Typography becomes a mode of interpretation’. 
The traditional understanding of pictures being read and words being seen was redefined by Katherine McCoy.  Readers were challenged to produce their own meanings through her model of ‘typography as discourse’.
The ‘user’ was defined at the end of the 1990’s from human computer interaction (HCI) studies.  Lupton ummarizes the importance of the user over the reader or writer perfectly.  
‘How texts are used becomes more important than what they mean’
Interactive systems, whilst offering the user self-direction and control, are also deviously gathering data about the user.   Users of websites are impatient and expect to be productive not because of the visual display but because of the culture of the Internet. Text is seen as inferior as a universal mode of communication to icons/pictures, a misconception triggered by the persistent use of icons in digital technology.  Text in fact supports users understanding as it can be searched, reformatted, restyled and translated. Users are actually shaping future information systems by choosing what to look at. They prize function over form.  The 21st century designer has to develop strategies to capture the dominant ‘user’s’ attention.
Deconstruction and Graphic Design

Deconstruction in graphic design is defined by Lupton & Miller in Design Writing Research 'Rather than look at deconstruction as a historical period or style, we see deconstruction as a critical process - an act of questioning'. Later in the essay they went on to say about Deconstruction ' Instead of viewing it as an 'ism' of the late 80's and early 90's,we see it as part of the ongoing development of design and typography as distinctive modes of representation'

The work of Graphic Designer David Carson exemplifies Deconstruction in Graphic Design. 

The image below is one of many Editorial designs for Ray Gun magazine covers. This cover was Art directed by Chris Ashworth.
There are several messages represented here and the design forces the reader to work to uncover the messages.  This is apparent immediately as there is no obvious headline and the designer has used spacing erratically and not to define words for example the name BRIANWILSON and even the magazine header RA Y G UN. By using different size fonts, capital letters and layering he makes reader search for meaning.  The true meaning or content is only deciphered when you read the smallest font on the page... 'the5iftymostinfluentialpeopleinpop culture' ... This again has been made almost unreadable with inappropriate spacing, and by doubling the type.  There are also several words and names upside down and cut off again to play with the conventions of reading.He also includes several suggestive icons such as the cut off recycling symbol.  Maybe to suggest these people are interchangeable?
The layering used has sliced the top of Andy Warhol's head off which is not an accident.  Lupton and Abbott discuss a magazine cover for NYQ in Design Writing Research, they describe the cover design as having  'explicitly manipulated a cultural artifact'.
RayGun was an alternative Rock n roll magazine first published in November 1992. By 1998, the experimental typographic design was well established to the alternative audience it attracted and suited the cutting edge music the magazine explored.

The deconstruction attitude was not just reserved for the cover. The even, unified texture of the typographic grid has been completely ignored and he has used the shape of the text body to create spaces.


Is Techno Dead? 1994. Title absorbed into the layout, body copy generates major shapes across the spread, empathizing the heavy techno mix. Photo John Ritter' Quote and image from David Carson's Website. David Carson who did not formally study graphic design cites his designs as 'intuitive'.  Of the designers recommended as examples for Deconstruction, he is one that did not attend the Cranbrook Academy of Art whose graduates had been influenced by Post-structuralism and Barthes theory. Which came first intuition or theory driven practice? 
http://www.dcorona.com/art356/deconstruction.about/index.html 

►Image Deconstruction - Barbara Kruger

Barbara Kruger is a contemporary artist who uses photographs (sometimes appropriated imagery) along with provocative statements.  Oftentimes this imagery is not viewed as a traditional gallery piece, but in the context of a billboard (as an advertisement for example).  I am attracted to the aesthetics of her work as well as the compelling juxtapositions of image and text that she uses.  Their resulting meanings (generally socially or culturally pointed in nature) are also quite intriguing.


Historical context
Time of work and style...
This work was produced in 1987, although the illustration style, hairstyles, and clothing of the two children pictured seem to reference an earlier time which is not contemporary.  My guess would be that the children pictured are plucked from a mid-century advertisement or illustration.  It is particularly graphic in terms of media, and is likely a serigraph in a fairly commercial style (common of Kruger’s work).


Cultural context
The culture that it was created by and for...
As aforementioned, Kruger’s images have a commercial resonance due to their formal language of high contrast, superimposed text, and large scale.  As Americans, we are used to seeing similar images on billboards and in magazines.  However, some of Kruger’s images (this one in particular) use imagery from print sources of the past.  Both figures are Caucasian and the text is in English, so one might assume the work is produced by and for a Western culture.


Social context
Social conditions of the time and place that the work was created in and for...
This particular piece was produced in the 1980s – a time known for both excess and innovation, and by some standards progress.  Kruger’s image seems to both simultaneously question and accept gender stereotypes of the times prior to and coinciding with the time it was produced.  Though I was just a child at the time this was produced, I remembered seeing (and hearing) about how the role of women was changing – yet again.  Strains of Dolly Parton singing “9 to 5” provided the background theme song for briefcase-toting Day to Night Barbie (fashionable in both the workplace and at night!) that I played with waiting for my own mother to return home from her job.  With shoulder pads flared I saw women literally attempting to stand shoulder to shoulder with men in the workplace at the time.  Kruger’s piece seems to nod to my memories, as well, as to question whether or not these changes were really taking place.  Had women really come all that far or had we just surrendered our Rosie the Riveter pose to the boys once again?


►You Are Not Yourself: The work of Barbara Kruger

Barbara Kruger, certainly one of the most recognizable and influential contemporary female artists, is a woman whose style and statements transcend the mundane designs of modern signage. Appearing in such places as on the back of matchbooks, billboards, shopping bags, t-shirts, television, and in subway cars, as well as exhibited in public spaces around the world, Barbara Kruger’s work sneaks up to viewers and makes them pay attention.


Her style is bold and arresting: white Futura lettering highlighted by a vibrant red rectangle placed over black and white photographs. This format is visually punching and not only because of the dynamic red and geometric typeface. It is most striking do to Kruger’s careful juxtaposition of iconic images and the text that she stamps over each photograph. In this manner Kruger, with so few words, actually says quite a bit.

Born in 1945 in Newark, New Jersey, Kruger attended Syracuse University in 1964 followed by a semester at Parsons School of Design in New York City where she studied alongside famous photographer Diane Arbus. Kruger went on to work for Mademoiselle where she would be named head designer the following year. Working through the 60’s Kruger made a living from her various graphic design endeavors.


But during the socially tumultuous decades of the 60’s and 70’s Kruger began to take a deeper interest in the social and political movements of the time, feeling that such issues should be reflected in her designs as well. Focusing on concerns such as, and not excluded to, gender, race, sexuality, consumerism and cultural stereotypes, Kruger studied the works of critical theorists such as Benjamin and Barthes while teaching at the University of California in the mid-70’s. As Kruger’s socio-political awareness progressed, so did her designs.
In 1979 Kruger published a book of photographs entitled Picture/Readings in which photos of architectural structures are juxtaposed with text about the people who inhabit these constructions. The language and approach Kruger began to take with this publication would inform her artistic voice in the decade to come.
The 80’s fostered numerous social movements in America, particularly feminism. It was also at this time that Kruger solidified her trademark style of ironic juxtaposition, the weapon she employs to comment on such movements. During the 80’s much of feminist art focused on deconstruction and the "decentering" of ideas, a concept introduced by the French philosopher Jaques Derrida. Deconstruction encourages people to reject the notion, in traditional western philosophy, of a center or an all-encompassing truth.
The idea of a center is a construction of our society and the language we use deceives us into believing that the world really is and only can be structured in this way. Perhaps in approaching the constructions of our society in a new "decentered" manner we will no longer be trapped by language in a mode of oppositional thinking, which creates hierarchical distinctions such as male and female. Kruger employs this idea of deconstruction in her work to escape meta-narratives, the order mandated by our culture that structures our knowledge and experiences. 


Before continuing to analyze Kruger with this lens it is important to acknowledge that although this description cites Kruger’s academic and political influences, the tone of her work is not dense. Rather, Kruger invites the viewer into an informal dialogue with her pieces by using pronouns such as ‘I,’ ‘you’ or ‘us’ where usually the ‘you’ refers to men and the ‘us’ refers to women.
For example, in her piece Your Gaze Hits The Side of My Face (1981) the head of a female sculpture is turned so that only one side of its face is exposed with the text of the title placed over the image. We may ascertain that ‘your gaze’ refers to what the feminist author Laura Mulvey has called the "male gaze."In cinema women are objectified through the framing technique of the camera and are also trained as female audience members to look at those on screen through a masculine lens—the "male gaze". Kruger’s wit makes the viewer see how silly the emphasis on the male gaze is in our culture as it causes the viewer to miss something more, in this case, the rest of this woman’s face. Because of gender stereotypes in our society, perhaps the male gaze can only one side of femininity too. 

 
Despite the academic undertones in Kruger’s work, her pieces often have a casual and facetious quality. In fact, most of Kruger’s work has an ironic grace that prevents the viewer from feeling accosted by the pieces’ socially driven message. First her signs address you with the use of pronouns, then they entertain you with clever text, later they cause you to question why they are amusing, and finally her pieces indicate that the humorousness comes from something deeper in our society. 

Kruger’s You Are Not Yourself (1982) uses this humorous technique to underscore a feminist point of view. The words ‘you are not yourself’ are disjointedly laid over a photograph of a distressed woman looking into a shattered mirror. This montage is immediately ironic because you are looking into a mirror, the object our culture relies on to reflect reality, but it is cracked and without its reassurance you are not yourself. Somehow without the recognition of the mirror, the axis of our culture, your own existence is in question. This begs the question why are you not yourself? Continuing with the theme of feminist art, Kruger is perhaps indicating that you are not yourself because our culture, ruled by the mirror and the media, mandates that you be one thing that you are not or possibly may never be. Kruger is commenting on the unreality of the ideal female image portrayed by the media and she will revisit the stereotypical female role in later pieces Super Rich/Ultra Gorgeous/Extra Skinny/Forever Young (1997). 

Kruger’s well known I Shop Therefore I Am (1990) is another arresting design with academic undertones. The title of the piece, of course in white Futura letting, is written in a red rectangle and held between the thumb and middle finger as though it were a credit card or some sort or identification. A clear reference to Descartes “I think therefore I am,” Kruger jokingly implies that in our society consumerism is valued and elevated to a level so high it supersedes consciousness. But on some levels could this be more than a joke? After all, a joke is usually half of the truth. Just think of the numbing effects advertising can have. There is more than humor in Kruger’s piece. Although, the fact that the design was featured on a shopping bag is quite entertaining, particularly for the person who sees someone else carrying it. 

With such enjoyable and socially charged designs, Barbara Kruger has led a successful career as an artist and also as an author, writing for such publications as The New York Times and The Village Voice. Kruger is also politically well known for her piece Your Body Is a Battleground (1989) which was used as the poster for a pro-choice march in Washington DC. Her vast portfolio of work addresses issues cultural stereotypes, state and domestic violence, identity, gender, sexuality, and even political and social power. 


In 2006 Kruger collaborated on a show in Paris entitled “How’s Love Doing” which explored the status of love in today’s world. Kruger forgoes her trademark style of red highlighting for this exhibit, but continues to emphasize her view on the physical verses emotional state of love through the careful pairing of specific text and images. With her insightful juxtapositions, often through re-contextualizing iconic American images (as in We Don’t Need Another Hero), Kruger is able to direct our attention to the social issues facing American culture today, if not change our outlook altogether. Barbara Kruger’s unique approach to bringing the world into her artwork invites us to enjoy; but more importantly she challenges us to think.

As Kruger so candidly describes, "Look, we’re all saddled with things that make us better or worse. This world is a crazy place, and I’ve chosen to make my work about that insanity."

►Poststructuralism & Deconstruction

Thursday, December 1, 2011

►Theodor W. Adorno - Philosophy of New Music

THE NEW TRANSLATION AND REPUBLICATION of Theodor Adorno’s Philosophy of New Music is a further clarification of modernism, necessitated by the latest discontents with postmodernism’s vulgarization, which keeps it at a fictitious distance. Perhaps as his remedy for the most fragmented part of the whole of the arts, namely music, translator Robert Hullot-Kentor has in recent years been steadily reintroducing Adorno’s aesthetic philosophy to English readers. The republication of Philosophy of New Music continues this process, further introducing readers to Adorno’s complex aesthetic theory, also elaborated recently in Current of Music, which embodies Adorno’s aesthetic hopes for the early emergence of radio transmission. Republishing Philosophy of New Music serves the purpose of clarifying a nexus of art history where the relationship between aesthetics and theory could have been drastically reformulated.

Theodor W. Adorno (September 11, 1903 – August 6, 1969) was a German sociologist, philosopher, and musicologist known for his critical theory of society.
Philosophy of New Music is one of Adorno’s more obscure, niche analyses. Split into two sections comprising intricate dissections of Schoenberg and Stravinsky, it is tighter and less ambitious than Dialectic of Enlightenment, co-written with Max Horkheimer around the same time. However, New Music can be understood as Dialectic’s complement, its object being entangled with that of the culture industry critiqued generally in the more famous volume from the same period. Operating in an inverse way, Philosophy of New Music seeks to exacerbate and expose the same symptoms from within modernist music itself. American readers may have a difficult entry into the text, not only because the writing styles itself on Schoenberg’s esoteric manner of composition, but also because of Adorno’s object of critique, the historical complications provoking the European modernist avant-garde. The text pays strict attention to Schoenberg’s music technique, while delving into historical comparisons to previous composers like Richard Wagner and the regressive, constrictive trajectory implied by their music styles. The volume also incorporates some of Adorno’s most sustained ruminations on the changed significance of the musical “material,” one of Adorno’s most pivotal and least understood concepts for approaching new music as a response to rapidly changing social conditions. As a concept, it seeks to articulate possibilities emanating from the split in idealization and materialization in art—possibilities we now identify as reaching a climax with the music of the mid-century avant-garde that Adorno anticipated.
Autrian composer Arnold Schoenberg (1874–1951), whose works Adorno considers at length in Philosophy of New Music.
Philosophy of New Music thwarts the tired criticism of Adorno’s writing as elitist, ambiguous, generalizing, or abstract. His critique of Schoenberg adheres so meticulously to the composer’s actual technique that, in the process, he demonstrates the ability of objective analysis to destabilize an already contingent aesthetic construction by way of acute specificity. Early on, Adorno attacks status quo criticism of avant-garde music: “Amongst the reproaches that [mainstream critics] obstinately repeat, the most prevalent charge is the charge of intellectualism, the claim that new music springs from the head, not the heart or the ear….[Such criticisms] are put forward as if the tonal idiom were itself given by nature….The second nature of the tonal system is an illusion originating in history” . Already discernible are the grounds for his more well-known critiques of mass deception through pop music. The simplistic charge of elitism leveled against Adorno’s critique emerges out of bourgeois radical culture itself and represents a failure to comprehend the complicated forms of new music’s material reckoning with tonal idiom. It thus implies an exhaustion of that history’s potential. Bourgeois society’s inability to listen to Schoenberg manifests a disintegration of historical consciousness and the surprising reification of a history (tonal progression) which seemed the very opposite of stasis. For Adorno, a dogmatic concretizing of this tonal illusion pre-echoes the same consciousness pop music is a response to, as its development is bound up in both radical and mainstream aesthetics. This is elaborated in the section “Radical Music Is Not Immune,” where—in a style which itself reflects the formal contortions of modern artists like Schoenberg who “realize total enlightenment in themselves, regardless of the cunning naïveté of the culture industry”—Adorno asserts that “they also simultaneously make themselves like the internal structure of what they oppose and enter into opposition with their own intentions”. A relentless train of self-contained, monolithic statements like these, poetically mobilized to question their own truth content, forms the pointilist mimicry that comprises the whole of the Schoenberg analysis. Likewise, the literary technique of connecting immense paragraphs sans line-breaks (identical in form to Samuel Beckett’s contemporary novel trilogy, which Adorno admired) echoes the calculated and monotonous historical transformation from a dynamic music to one of stasis: “the music no longer presents itself as being in a process of development”.

The first part of the book, “Schoenberg and Progress,” introduces the issue of musical style as the hardening against suffering briefly alluded to in Dialectic of Enlightenment. “What radical music knows is the untransfigured suffering of men whose powerlessness has so increased that it no longer permits semblance and play”. Schoenberg’s music, in its strict form and restrictive technique, itself expresses the decline of human subjectivity, allowing it to surface only with dire earnestness. Schoenberg’s music embodies Adorno’s modern art philosophy. It exemplifies the true art he so intensely argued for, in contradistinction to the false ideology “innervated” in Stravinsky’s restoration, which allowed a “binding quality” back into the work. Better a rigorous, elitist art exposing the true, complicated bleakness of declining subjectivity than a fantasized, populist escapism. Though neatly divided into two opposed sections, Schoenberg and Stravinsky each express for Adorno the same individual-consuming “apparatus” of society.

Russian composer Igor Stravinsky (1882–1971), who wrote the ballets The Firebird (1910) and The Rite of Spring (1913). In Stravinsky’s highly structured compositional techniques, Adorno identifies a regressive tendency.
Stravinsky represents all the regressive, destructive complications of a solidarity desperate to maintain the illusion of identity. To Adorno, Stravinsky’s music is a calculated mechanism of meandering unintentionality and impressionist lightness (differing from Schoenberg’s heavy sound masses). As a mass ornamentation, it summons the audience to rally together to annihilate their own subjectivity. Adorno dissects how Stravinsky’s music embodies modernism’s paradoxes, incorporating a romanticized primitivism while retaining an impressionist ephemerality of rapidly changing styles. Ritual and sacrifice are significant problems in Stravinsky’s music, and Adorno describes their manipulative function in quelling individual subjectivity, a function that is only heightened by Stravinsky’s mastery of a style that is both the culmination of history and also ironically its own nihilistic undoing. Adorno notes the ubiquitous trend when he suggests that Stravinsky unwittingly strikes the same nerve as the psychologist C. J. Jung: “The search for musical equivalents to the ‘collective unconscious’ prepare for the transition to the establishment of the regressive community as a positive achievement” . The same regressive impulse extends to the identification with nature in music: “The pressure of reified Bourgeois culture incites flight into the phantasm of nature, which then ultimately proves to be the herald of absolute oppression. The aesthetic nerve quivers to return to the stone age” . Almost unflinchingly, the reader can freely associate Stravinsky’s ritualist spectacle with reprises of the same in contemporary culture (Lady Gaga’s primitive masks embedded in a stylized futurism, and the neo-pastoralism now prevalent in “experimental” drone and electronic folk music, not to mention precious back-to-the-land motifs in contemporary art).

The delusion that Adorno articulates is the same delusion we share today. For this reason, Philosophy of New Music is a primary historical artifact for gleaning the impetus of earlier stages of still-crystallizing collective grotesqueness. At first, readers may interpret this text as mere analysis, uncritically adopting the back-cover’s claim that the book somehow represents Adorno’s “manifesto.” But the more the reader grapples with the criticism the volume contains, the more she begins to understand that this text is more than anything else a manifesto on how criticism could actively participate in and clarify artistic concerns, immanently complicating solidarity between theory and practice. That the text has collected so much dust, and that when divorced from its hopes of intellectual action the manifesto socially degrades into the pure “theory” we today (mis)understand it to be, embodies the tragic failure of Adorno’s emancipatory modernism.
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...